I decided to go with bachelor #1. When riding him I felt so safe and at ease, something that I haven't in so, so long. I've ridden for over 22yrs and I know what I like and what I don't. I'll take safe and sane over fancy and flighty any day.
His name on the ad was Push Button, aka PB, both of which I wasn't supper fond of. But when I went to pick him up they said they also call him Peebs, Paddy, and Paddington Bear. I know there's already a Paddy in blogland but I like it and think it suits him. I'm thinking Paddy for his barn name and either Sir Paddington or just Paddington as a show name.